Good evening Chairman Daley and commissioners. My name is Kulmeet Galhotra. I am an assistant public defender in Cook County and President of AFSCME Local 3315, the union that represents the front-line public defenders in Cook County.
I am here to tell you that President Preckwinkle’s proposed budget, which will result in the layoffs of 63 attorneys, and half of our investigators and support staff, is nothing more than a shell game that is going to cost the citizens of Cook County far more than it will ever save.
The Public Defender’s office plays a vital role in the administration of justice in this county. We represent those folks who cannot afford to hire an attorney in misdemeanors, preliminary hearings, bond court, felonies, homicides, child protection, juvenile justice, appeals, post conviction and traffic court in Chicago and suburban Cook County. The responsibility for providing effective assistance of counsel, to the accused poor, rests with the county and ultimately, with you the commissioners.
Despite caseloads that are still in excess of ABA guidelines, the Public Defender’s Office continues to provide its clients with the finest legal representation. A study last year of 2850 criminal cases in Cook County by researchers from the University of Texas concluded that public defenders get results that are just as good as their private counterparts. And if you consider the number of cases our office handles with the amount of money that we were funded in 2010, you find that our office is more efficient than the public defender systems in Missouri, Iowa, Minnesota and Wisconsin. Some states, like Massachusetts are actually considering creating a public defender system and getting rid of their private attorney appointment system. Why? Because public defender systems are cost-effective. But cuts to our office with the current budget proposal will lead to fewer public defenders and the County will wind up paying private attorneys more money to do our jobs.
In addition, cutting the Public Defender’s budget by 10% will translate into increasing the time it will take us to dispose cases, which will have an incremental effect on the costs of housing pretrial detainees at Cook County Jail. And then there is always the specter of civil actions brought against the County by defendants who had to wait too long to have their case heard or had overworked public defenders.
Cook county may be required by law to balance its budget by the end of February, but the Constitution requires Cook County to pay for lawyers for poor people. In the long run, President Preckwinkle’s budget would increase costs to the taxpayers, while ignoring our Constitution’s sacred promise of “equal justice for all.”